Showing posts with label ethics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ethics. Show all posts

Monday, September 15, 2008

Churches challenge IRS policy

There is an interesting fight going on right now between religious groups over the proper role of politics and religion. A Phoenix-based organization called the Alliance Defense Fund has encouraged ministers around the country to give political sermons on Sunday, September 28. The ADF wished to challenge an IRS restriction that would remove a church's tax-exempt status if pastors endorse of political candidates, and has offered to represent any church investigated by the IRS as a result of any political sermon delivered on that day. It even suggests that participating pastors The defense fund has met with opposition from other religious organizations, however, that disagree with the fund's purpose. Fifty-five religious leaders have filed a complaint with the IRS to stop the ADF's plan.

As is often the case, the story is a little more complicated than it may initially seem. For example, many of the religious leaders that complained to the IRS are from the more liberal United Church of Christ, whereas the Alliance Defense Fund is a conservative Christian group. UCC ministers might also be a little wary of such a proposal after it was investigated by the IRS in 2007 after hosting Barack Obama at its convention.

Despite the protests, more than three dozen ministers from 20 states have signed up to participate in the "pulpit plan." However, don't expect any political endorsements from LDS pulpits on September 28. (Not authorized ones, at any rate -- I'm sure we have all heard a few politically-charged testimony meetings.) The LDS Church's stance on political neutrality is regularly reaffirmed through open letters and press releases, particularly during political campaign seasons. You could look at this as the Church putting into practice the doctrine contained in the Twelth Article of Faith, "obeying, honoring, and sustaining the [tax] law." Of course, the financial repricussions of losing its 501(c)(3) tax-exempt status might also be a wee bit persuasive. Besides, the ADR plan is probably aimed at individual congregations, rather than a large centralized church. The LDS Church has the resources to defend itself in a court of law, but that doesn't make it any more likely to pick a legal fight.

Tuesday, August 14, 2007

A Good Lawyer

Here's a few thoughts on the legal life and work of President James E. Faust, who passed away last week at age 87.

A quote from President Faust in the Spring 2003 Clark Memorandum, p. 7:
The pursuit of justice is a very noble path, but obtaining justice is often very elusive …. In some ways a more noble effort is to resolve differences by being a peacemaker.
From his obituary in the Deseret News:
The son of an attorney and judge, President Faust gravitated naturally to a law career. After claiming a juris doctorate from the University of Utah Law School in 1948, he practiced law in Salt Lake City until his call as an Assistant to the Twelve on Oct. 6, 1972.

Public service was a notable element of President Faust's life during his professional career. He served as a Democratic member of the Utah Legislature from 1949-1951. He also served as an adviser to the American Bar Journal and was president of the Utah Bar Association in 1962-1963. He was also appointed by President John F. Kennedy to the Lawyers Committee on Civil Rights and Racial Unrest.
From an address to the BYU Law School on November 22, 1987:
The canons of ethics and the rules of court with which you must be familiar are helpful rules of conduct to abide by, but I have always believed that they are the lesser law. An attorney's own careful conscience and his own standards of high integrity ultimately ought to govern his conduct.

Friday, September 29, 2006

The Best Policy

I caught part of the new show Shark last night, and I was rather annoyed with the characters' blatant dishonesty. It probably makes for more exciting television, but portraying crooked lawyers is old hack by now. I've met my fair share of shady defense attorneys, but none of them were so blatant (or stupid) as the young A.D.A.'s in the show. I think it's one more reason why the world needs more conscientious and ethical attorneys. Ironically, this was one of the Reuters headlines this morning:

SYDNEY (Reuters) - A law student who used taxis to escape with loot from dozens of house break-ins has been jailed after police in Australia caught him red-handed in the back of a cab fleeing his latest heist.

When not studying for a masters degree in law, Phillip Ryan See, 27, used his off-time to rob 43 houses in Sydney's plush harbourside suburbs, netting goods worth more than A$110,000 ($83,000), the Sydney Morning Herald newspaper said on Thursday.

See, who once worked as a legal assistant in a government law office, would load plasma televisions, cameras, jewelry and laptop computers into the boot of a taxi after each raid.

But when a surprised home-owner discovered See during a midnight burglary, police arrested the would-be legal eagle escaping in the back of another taxi.

During a search of See's flat, police found one of their own uniforms stolen during another break-in.

See was jailed for four years and nine months after the judge accepted he had a psychotic disorder.
I guess it's never too early to blow your legal career. Sometimes (read: all the time) honesty really is the best policy.